| 1 | Phil Schenkenberg 2010–2026 |
St. Anthony Norsemen |
124 |
| 2 | Isaac Wales 2014–2026 |
Red West Legends, Waconia Islanders |
97 |
| 3 | Tim Noyes 2014–2026 |
Saint Paul JTs, Mill City Flour Sacks, Minnetonka Saints, St. Croix Valley Silverbacks |
94 |
| 4 | Terry Knop 2010–2026 |
Twin Cities Metropolitans, South Metro Saints |
86 |
| 5 | Mark Worms 2010–2026 |
St. Michael Angels |
84 |
| 6 | Ryan Marshall 2010–2026 |
St. Louis Park Snappers |
79 |
| 6 | Tony Brown 2010–2026 |
Minnetonka Mustangs |
79 |
| 8 | Mark Koritz 2013–2025 |
Minnetonka Mustangs |
76 |
| 9 | Paul Jaunich 2013–2026 |
Hamel / Cavaliers, Saint Paul JTs, Rockford Rail Splitters |
75 |
| 9 | Ken Rein 2014–2026 |
Saint Paul JTs |
75 |
| 11 | Keith Jacobsen 2010–2024 |
Hamel / Cavaliers, Rockford Rail Splitters |
74 |
| 12 | Todd Haag 2014–2026 |
Hamel / Cavaliers, Rockford Rail Splitters |
73 |
| 13 | Chris Freeman 2010–2026 |
St. Paul Senators, Burnsville Bulldogs, Lakeville Bulldogs |
72 |
| 14 | Nate Green 2015–2024 |
Hamel / Cavaliers, Rockford Rail Splitters |
69 |
| 14 | Mark Von Ruden 2020–2026 |
Minnoka Grays |
69 |
| 16 | Trevor Stolhanske 2014–2026 |
St. Louis Park Snappers, Lakeville Lobos |
63 |
| 16 | Paul Bennett 2010–2023 |
Coon Rapids Diamonds, Red West Legends |
63 |
| 18 | Jeff Mertens 2010–2026 |
Twin Cities Metropolitans, Minnetonka Mustangs |
62 |
| 18 | Jason Woebler 2011–2022 |
St. Louis Park Snappers, Minnetonka Mustangs |
62 |
| 18 | Micheal Eicher 2015–2026 |
Minnetonka Saints |
62 |
| 21 | Matt Jordan 2015–2026 |
St. Anthony Norsemen |
61 |
| 21 | Joe McCluskey 2010–2026 |
RC Rockets, Capital City Cannons, Milltown Outlaws, Veseli Vulcans |
61 |
| 23 | Paul Morita 2010–2026 |
St. Anthony Norsemen |
60 |
| 23 | Dustin Gingerich 2013–2026 |
St. Anthony Norsemen |
60 |
| 23 | Tom Larsen 2013–2026 |
Webster Wildcats, Veseli Vulcans, St. Patrick Shamrocks |
60 |